Summary tables

Photo by Allison Shelley for EDUimages

Unlocking Student Sensemaking: Why Summary Tables Are a Game-Changer in Science Classrooms

As educators, we're constantly seeking tools that not only help students grasp complex scientific ideas but also empower them to think like scientists. Imagine a single tool that acts as a roadmap for your unit, a journal for your students, and a catalyst for deep scientific discourse. That tool is the Summary Table, and research and classroom experience show it can significantly benefit student learning in science.

What is a Summary Table?

At its core, a summary table is a visual representation of how learning activities link together to explain a phenomenon or answer a driving question. Typically structured with columns and rows, the columns often represent different aspects of the learning process, such as:

  • The activity performed (experiment, simulation, reading, etc.)

  • Observations, evidence, or patterns noticed during the activity

  • The reasoning behind those observations (the science concept)

  • How this new understanding connects back to the overarching phenomenon or driving question

Each row of the table usually corresponds to a specific activity or lesson within a unit. This structure helps students document their developing understanding across the entire storyline of a unit.

Sample of Summary Table for upper elementary, middle school, and high school created by Einstein Project.

Sample Summary Chart for elementary students created by Einstein Project.

5 Key Benefits of Using Summary Tables in the Classroom

  1. Helps Students Make Sense of Their Learning
     Summary tables give students a structured way to organize observations, track ideas across lessons, and connect those ideas to the anchoring phenomenon or driving question.

  2. Builds Coherence Across the Unit
     The table helps students link each activity to the bigger picture, supporting a more cohesive and connected understanding of the science content.

  3. Supports Productive Discussions and Argumentation
     Summary tables make student thinking visible and provide a shared reference point for class discussions, critique, and collaborative sensemaking.

  4. Encourages Reflection and Ownership of Ideas
     As students revisit and update the table, they can see how their thinking evolves, compare it to class ideas, and reflect on their own learning.

  5. Equitably Develops Scientific Thinking
     Using everyday language first allows all students to engage deeply, especially emergent multilinguals, before introducing formal vocabulary and helping them connect claims to evidence and reasoning.

Research and Implementation Support

The benefits of summary tables are supported by both research and documented classroom implementation. A study in a middle school classroom using summary tables to scaffold scientific arguments during a plate tectonics unit found that the tables facilitated sense-making, supported the development of sophisticated explanations, and encouraged open critique of claims and evidence. This research highlights the table's role in documenting evolving understanding and structuring discourse. Classroom examples show how teachers use the tables to structure discussions, gather evidence, and connect learning to the driving question, often adjusting the column labels to fit the specific unit while maintaining the core sensemaking purpose.

In conclusion, incorporating summary tables into your science classroom routine is a powerful pedagogical shift. They provide a clear structure for students to organize their learning, make explicit connections between activities and the larger phenomenon, and engage in the critical discourse necessary for developing robust scientific explanations.

3 Resources to Dig Deeper…

2 Questions to Ponder & Discuss

  • In what ways can I use the summary table to support more inclusive participation in classroom discussions—especially for students who may be hesitant to share or are developing language skills?

  • How might the structure of the summary table help students organize their claims, evidence, and reasoning more effectively in written or verbal explanations?

1 Action to Take

Start Small with a Lesson-Based Summary Table

Choose one lesson in your current or upcoming unit and introduce a simple summary table with your students. Use it to capture what they figure out during the activity and how it connects to the driving question. Reflect afterward on how it supported student thinking and discussion.

Kim LembergerStudent Sensemaking, teaching strategies, summary tables, storyline, coherencyComment